Putting the "User" into User Experience Management
April 19, 2018

Dennis Drogseth
EMA

Share this

In the course of researching, documenting and advising on user experience management needs and directions for more than a decade, I've found myself waging a quiet (and sometimes not so quiet) war with several industry assumptions. Chief among these is the notion that user experience management (UEM) is purely a subset of application performance management (APM). This APM-centricity misses some of UEM's most critical value points, and in a basic sense fails to recognize what UEM is truly about.

What research over the course of ten years has consistently shown is that UEM is at core a two-way mirror. One side of the mirror indeed looks back at the application and its performance in terms of transactional latencies as the end user experiences them. But the other side of the mirror looks out at the end user/consumer with an eye to productivity, application usability, business impact, usage, value and relevance.

The 6 Dimensions of UEM

The next step in looking at UEM from an end-user perspective is to consider the use-case values documented in our research. EMA has validated six UEM use-case values, of which application performance is only one. These are listed based on prevalence — what people are actually doing. (When ranked by importance, the order stayed the same except that business impact outranked application performance.)

Application performance: This is the most tilted toward pureplay APM, and yet it, too, will gain from insights into user/consumer interactions relevant to completing critical business processes or other transactions.

Business impact: Here understanding the user is front and center — as most business outcomes are ultimately generated (and measurable) via end-user interactions, whether in terms of business process efficiencies, or customer/consumer outcomes.

Change management: Changes made to applications are often viewed in purely technical terms by IT. But in reality, any new application release may cause issues that transcend server or network performance. Validating change without understanding end-user impact is a story only partly told.

Design: Here end-user interaction is key, and far too often neglected. What looks good to developers in the back office may not work in real-world situations. UEM can document behaviors that not only suggest latency issues, but problems with application look and feel.

User productivity: This is all about the end-user interacting with the application. Some relevant productivity metrics ranked by their prevalence in real-world deployments are as follows:
- User productivity (number of processes executed)
- User effectiveness (success versus failure ratio)
- User efficiency (number of steps per process)
- User identification (time zone, location, computer name, IP)
- User attributes (geography, department, role)
- User proficiency (number of errors)

With this information, an entire portrait of user/consumer behavior can be mapped, understood and optimized, whether through changes in the application, improved app delivery, or actual training.

Service usage: Once again this is all about how, where, and potentially even why the end-user interacts with applications.

In the Last 3 Years …

Speaking of service usage, it isn't so surprising that in EMA's most recent research, the two areas that have become most important to UEM over the past three years are application performance and portfolio planning and optimization, which were tied for first place.

Putting the user into user experience management can provide insights into:

■ What's being used and what's not?

■ And to what effect?

■ What are the business outcomes?

■ What business processes are enhanced? Which are slowed?

■ And at what cost to business performance?

When it comes to truly optimizing application investments, all this data is critical both to IT and business stakeholders.

Business and IT Alignment Anyone?

More than anything else, applications are the "products" of IT — the core services through which businesses evolve and perform. Digital transformation wouldn't be "digital" without applications of some kind. And any smart product creator/deliverer will seriously invest in understanding how the consumers behave when engaging with their products, whether it's about toys, cars, cameras or — to take a modest leap in context — SAP.

When we asked if user experience management was an IT concern, a business concern, or a joint IT-to-business concern, the responses were consistent with years past:

■ 20% felt that UEM is primarily a business concern

■ 21% felt that UEM is primarily an IT concern

59% recognized the truth: UEM is (or should be) equally an IT and a business concern

There's Always More

Putting the user into UEM has many additional values. For instance, in creating a true common ground between development and operations for DevOps, where not only performance, but usability and design can be understood in both pre- and post-production environments. With the right linkages, understanding end-user behaviors will also bring value in industry compliance, business process assessments, and, needless to say, to training needs for complex business-critical ERP and other applications. It can also help to unify operations and service desk insights into a truly integrated strategy for UEM across all of IT.

The list continues, but hopefully I've made my point. And I welcome yours. Feel free to reach out to me at drogseth@emausa.com

Dennis Drogseth is VP at Enterprise Management Associates (EMA)
Share this

The Latest

May 23, 2019

The first word in APM technology is "Application" ... yet for mobile, apps are entirely different. As the mobile app ecosystem is evolving and expanding from pure entertainment to more utilitarian uses, there's a rising need for the next generation of APM technology to stay ahead of the issues that can cause apps to fail ...

May 22, 2019

For application performance monitoring (APM), many in IT tend to focus a significant amount of their time on the tool that performs the analysis. Unfortunately for them, the battle is won or lost at the data access level. If you don’t have the right data, you can’t fix the problem correctly ...

May 21, 2019

Findings of the Digital Employee Experience survey from VMware show correlation between enabling employees with a positive digital experience (i.e., device choice/flexibility, seamless access to apps, remote work capabilities) and an organization's competitive position, revenue growth and employee sentiment ...

May 20, 2019

In today's competitive landscape, businesses must have the ability and process in place to face new challenges and find ways to successfully tackle them in a proactive manner. For years, this has been placed on the shoulders of DevOps teams within IT departments. But, as automation takes over manual intervention to increase speed and efficiency, these teams are facing what we know as IT digitization. How has this changed the way companies function over the years, and what do we have to look forward to in the coming years? ...

May 16, 2019

Although the vast majority of IT organizations have implemented a broad variety of systems and tools to modernize, simplify and streamline data center operations, many are still burdened by inefficiencies, security risks and performance gaps in their IT infrastructure as well as the excessive time it takes to manage legacy infrastructure, according to the State of IT Transformation, a report from Datrium ...

May 15, 2019

When it comes to network visibility, there are a lot of discussions about packet broker technology and the various features these solutions provide to network architects and IT managers. Packet brokers allow organizations to aggregate the data required for a variety of monitoring solutions including network performance monitoring and diagnostic (NPMD) platforms and unified threat management (UTM) appliances. But, when it comes to ensuring these solutions provide the insights required by NetOps and security teams, IT can spend an exorbitant amount of time dealing with issues around adds, moves and changes. This can have a dramatic impact on budgets and tool availability. Why does this happen? ...

May 14, 2019

Data may be pouring into enterprises but IT professionals still find most of it stuck in siloed departments and weeks away from being able to drive any valued action. Coupled with the ongoing concerns over security responsiveness, IT teams have to push aside other important performance-oriented data in order to ensure security data, at least, gets prominent attention. A new survey by Ivanti shows the disconnect between enterprise departments struggling to improve operations like automation while being challenged with a siloed structure and a data onslaught ...

May 13, 2019

A subtle, deliberate shift has occurred within the software industry which, at present, only the most innovative organizations have seized upon for competitive advantage. Although primarily driven by Artificial Intelligence (AI), this transformation strikes at the core of the most pervasive IT resources including cloud computing and predictive analytics ...

May 09, 2019

When asked who is mandated with developing and delivering their organization's digital competencies, 51% of respondents say their IT departments have a leadership role. The critical question is whether IT departments are prepared to take on a leadership role in which collaborating with other functions and disseminating knowledge and digital performance data are requirements ...

May 08, 2019

The Economist Intelligence Unit just released a new study commissioned by Riverbed that explores nine digital competencies that help organizations improve their digital performance and, ultimately, achieve their objectives. Here's a brief summary of 7 key research findings you'll find covered in detail in the report ...