Envisioning Testing as a Three-Course Meal
September 26, 2022

Marcus Merrell
Sauce Labs

Share this

A Metaphorical Appetizer

Might we recommend a light and crisp prosecco?

In Italy, it is customary to treat wine as part of the meal. Wine isn't a beverage: wine is as integral to the meal as the food itself. The wine is the food. The food is the wine. They are inseparable, complementary.

Too often, testing is treated with the same reverence as the post-meal task of loading the dishwasher, when it should be treated like an elegant wine pairing: a test suite, properly written, gives you objective proof that your code is functioning properly, from the individual units to the full application. A passing suite of unit tests, executed after even a small change to someone else's code, gives you a dopamine hit almost as powerful as a sip of wine. If you treat testing like loading the dishwasher, you're probably overlooking details and missing steps. It's hard to care about details of any task you hate.

Like wine, tests can give you both pleasure and (given enough quantity) confidence.

To further stretch the metaphor: Testing can be off-loaded to a separate person or team — forgotten — just like loading the dishwasher. But everyone needs to eat, and everyone deserves the pleasure of a perfect pairing of wine with their dinner.

Photo from Mangia Michelle

The Main Course

Paired with a delightful Cabernet Sauvignon, or perhaps JUnit?

Unit Tests
Unit tests exist to ensure that a team's code works as correctly as it can. Few things are faster to execute than unit tests — we're talking about nanoseconds. You should have many of them, liberally sprinkled throughout the codebase. The bigger your team, the more you will thank yourself for requiring them. Unit tests apply equally to any kind of software project, including mobile apps.

Integration Tests
Integration tests ensure that one team's code interacts with other codebases as expected, and as it evolves and changes. They often talk to a microservice developed by another team. They don't execute as quickly as unit tests, but they are still blazingly fast — fractions of a second. Integration tests are critical to mobile testing in particular, because apps live and die by the function and efficiency of the APIs they use, and because so much of the mobile ecosystem beyond the API involves variables your team can't control.

Functional UI Tests
Functional UI tests are meant to string disparate parts of the system together, to ensure it works as a whole. These tests also tend to incorporate other kinds of software over which your team has zero control: web browsers, mobile devices, mobile operating systems, and background processes. As a result, these tests are exponentially slower than unit and integration tests.

As difficult as they are to develop and maintain, they are absolutely critical to the success of your app. Due to the complications of constant changes — to operating systems, libraries, and even mobile device hardware, the number of ways your code might be executed increases exponentially, and only testing can guarantee success.


A Tawny Port will do the trick. Or some Selenium.

And thus we leave our culinary metaphor behind. While I expect to receive immediate gratification from my meal at a four star restaurant, succession planning requires a different motivation.

Automated testing is a form of succession planning. Unit, integration, Functional tests — these are created by people who understand the requirements that were used to create the software, and they evolve to changes made, staying relevant or being excised as requirements are altered.

Thus this is where our testing meal metaphor ends. While I expect to receive immediate gratification from my meal at a four star restaurant, succession planning requires a different motivation.

I don't write tests for myself, for today.

I write tests for myself, for a year from now, when I have to change my code and I can't remember what I was thinking.

I write tests for a new developer who inherits the code base later, after I'm gone.

My tests set my successors up for success. The seeds of good testing are planted today, to create the beautiful vintage, your team will savor for years.

Marcus Merrell is VP of Technology Strategy at Sauce Labs
Share this

The Latest

March 27, 2023

To achieve maximum availability, IT leaders must employ domain-agnostic solutions that identify and escalate issues across all telemetry points. These technologies, which we refer to as Artificial Intelligence for IT Operations, create convergence — in other words, they provide IT and DevOps teams with the full picture of event management and downtime ...

March 23, 2023

APMdigest and leading IT research firm Enterprise Management Associates (EMA) are partnering to bring you the EMA-APMdigest Podcast, a new podcast focused on the latest technologies impacting IT Operations. In Episode 2 - Part 1 Pete Goldin, Editor and Publisher of APMdigest, discusses Network Observability with Shamus McGillicuddy, Vice President of Research, Network Infrastructure and Operations, at EMA ...

March 22, 2023

CIOs have stepped into the role of digital leader and strategic advisor, according to the 2023 Global CIO Survey from Logicalis ...

March 21, 2023

Synthetic monitoring is crucial to deploy code with confidence as catching bugs with E2E tests on staging is becoming increasingly difficult. It isn't trivial to provide realistic staging systems, especially because today's apps are intertwined with many third-party APIs ...

March 20, 2023

Recent EMA field research found that ServiceOps is either an active effort or a formal initiative in 78% of the organizations represented by a global panel of 400+ IT leaders. It is relatively early but gaining momentum across industries and organizations of all sizes globally ...

March 16, 2023

Managing availability and performance within SAP environments has long been a challenge for IT teams. But as IT environments grow more complex and dynamic, and the speed of innovation in almost every industry continues to accelerate, this situation is becoming a whole lot worse ...

March 15, 2023

Harnessing the power of network-derived intelligence and insights is critical in detecting today's increasingly sophisticated security threats across hybrid and multi-cloud infrastructure, according to a new research study from IDC ...

March 14, 2023

Recent research suggests that many organizations are paying for more software than they need. If organizations are looking to reduce IT spend, leaders should take a closer look at the tools being offered to employees, as not all software is essential ...

March 13, 2023

Organizations are challenged by tool sprawl and data source overload, according to the Grafana Labs Observability Survey 2023, with 52% of respondents reporting that their companies use 6 or more observability tools, including 11% that use 16 or more.

March 09, 2023

An array of tools purport to maintain availability — the trick is sorting through the noise to find the right one. Let us discuss why availability is so important and then unpack the ROI of deploying Artificial Intelligence for IT Operations (AIOps) during an economic downturn ...