Skip to main content

IT Monitoring Paradox: Let's Step Outside the Bubble!

David Hayward

The world is full of paradoxes. To solve them, you have to look at the facts in a different, even nonconventional way. You have to step outside your bubble.

One of the earliest paradoxes is from the ancient Greek thinker Heraclitus. It goes like this: "You cannot step into the same river twice." As Roy Sorenson says in A Brief History of the Paradox, "[Heraclitus] means that you cannot step twice into the same water of a river. There is one river, but many distinct bodies of water flow through it. Heraclitus urges a balance between experience and reason."

Paradoxes are fun to solve, but real-life they can be serious. IT Operations faces paradoxes too, and one in particular day in and day out. Recently, an IT Manager in a FORTUNE 1000 company — let's call him "Joe" — told me that he was called into the distribution center VP's office. The center was at a standstill. Joe showed him that the IT systems supporting the center were meeting all their Service Level Agreements: servers, applications, databases, storage, routers, switches — the whole lot. And the VP's response? "So what. I can’t ship anything."

That's when the light bulb went off in Joe's head. All the IT technologies that underlie the distribution center were running fine, but not the center itself. IT Operations needed another way to look at things, so he could understand the IT environment's status in terms of its impact on the business, not just in terms of how this or that technology silo was behaving.

Like Heraclitus and the river, Joe needed to strike a balance between experience and reason. Joe had plenty of experience — reams of performance monitoring data and proof of SLA compliance for each technology domain — but no way to reason, or monitor, the distribution center business process itself.

Joe started thinking of ITIL — the framework for orienting IT with services, not technologies, in mind. The trouble is, IT operates in a bubble. In fact, lots of bubbles: silo’d teams, silo’d tools, each separately monitoring servers, applications, storage, databases, routers, switches, etc.. No one was monitoring the big picture outside the bubbles. IT Operations Level 1 (the “first line of defense”) was looking at a sea of monitoring screens, events and alerts about technology devices and circuits, and had little or no understanding about how those events and alerts impacted specific business processes.

So even when IT was meeting SLA objectives in each silo, little degradations (i.e., incidents) across silos were adding up and impacting different services (i.e., processes and user experience) in different ways. This was undetectable because there wasn't any way to way to associate all those incidents with specific business services: no operational view and real-time IT operational analytics of business processes across silos.

This is typical. As an analyst from a leading IT research firm recently told me: "The Industry has been trying to solve this problem for decades. It sounds old, but we keep coming back to the same paradox over and over again."

Joe and others like him have embarked on a mission to transform IT Operations from a purely technology monitoring team to a business service reliability monitoring team. They are transforming operations because either they’ll crack the paradox of managing services that they deliver to their business, or the business will outsource operations to someone who can.

Transformation doesn't happen overnight. As the ITIL mantra teaches us, it takes "people, processes and technology" to get IT properly focused on the business and its services. To start, you need to step outside your bubble.

David Hayward is Senior Principal Manager, Solutions Marketing at CA Technologies.

Hot Topics

The Latest

E-commerce is set to skyrocket with a 9% rise over the next few years ... To thrive in this competitive environment, retailers must identify digital resilience as their top priority. In a world where savvy shoppers expect 24/7 access to online deals and experiences, any unexpected downtime to digital services can lead to significant financial losses, damage to brand reputation, abandoned carts with designer shoes, and additional issues ...

Efficiency is a highly-desirable objective in business ... We're seeing this scenario play out in enterprises around the world as they continue to struggle with infrastructures and remote work models with an eye toward operational efficiencies. In contrast to that goal, a recent Broadcom survey of global IT and network professionals found widespread adoption of these strategies is making the network more complex and hampering observability, leading to uptime, performance and security issues. Let's look more closely at these challenges ...

Image
Broadcom

The 2025 Catchpoint SRE Report dives into the forces transforming the SRE landscape, exploring both the challenges and opportunities ahead. Let's break down the key findings and what they mean for SRE professionals and the businesses relying on them ...

Image
Catchpoint

The pressure on IT teams has never been greater. As data environments grow increasingly complex, resource shortages are emerging as a major obstacle for IT leaders striving to meet the demands of modern infrastructure management ... According to DataStrike's newly released 2025 Data Infrastructure Survey Report, more than half (54%) of IT leaders cite resource limitations as a top challenge, highlighting a growing trend toward outsourcing as a solution ...

Image
Datastrike

Gartner revealed its top strategic predictions for 2025 and beyond. Gartner's top predictions explore how generative AI (GenAI) is affecting areas where most would assume only humans can have lasting impact ...

The adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) is accelerating across the telecoms industry, with 88% of fixed broadband service providers now investigating or trialing AI automation to enhance their fixed broadband services, according to new research from Incognito Software Systems and Omdia ...

 

AWS is a cloud-based computing platform known for its reliability, scalability, and flexibility. However, as helpful as its comprehensive infrastructure is, disparate elements and numerous siloed components make it difficult for admins to visualize the cloud performance in detail. It requires meticulous monitoring techniques and deep visibility to understand cloud performance and analyze operational efficiency in detail to ensure seamless cloud operations ...

Imagine a future where software, once a complex obstacle, becomes a natural extension of daily workflow — an intuitive, seamless experience that maximizes productivity and efficiency. This future is no longer a distant vision but a reality being crafted by the transformative power of Artificial Intelligence ...

Enterprise data sprawl already challenges companies' ability to protect and back up their data. Much of this information is never fully secured, leaving organizations vulnerable. Now, as GenAI platforms emerge as yet another environment where enterprise data is consumed, transformed, and created, this fragmentation is set to intensify ...

Image
Crashplan

OpenTelemetry (OTel) has revolutionized the way we approach observability by standardizing the collection of telemetry data ... Here are five myths — and truths — to help elevate your OTel integration by harnessing the untapped power of logs ...

IT Monitoring Paradox: Let's Step Outside the Bubble!

David Hayward

The world is full of paradoxes. To solve them, you have to look at the facts in a different, even nonconventional way. You have to step outside your bubble.

One of the earliest paradoxes is from the ancient Greek thinker Heraclitus. It goes like this: "You cannot step into the same river twice." As Roy Sorenson says in A Brief History of the Paradox, "[Heraclitus] means that you cannot step twice into the same water of a river. There is one river, but many distinct bodies of water flow through it. Heraclitus urges a balance between experience and reason."

Paradoxes are fun to solve, but real-life they can be serious. IT Operations faces paradoxes too, and one in particular day in and day out. Recently, an IT Manager in a FORTUNE 1000 company — let's call him "Joe" — told me that he was called into the distribution center VP's office. The center was at a standstill. Joe showed him that the IT systems supporting the center were meeting all their Service Level Agreements: servers, applications, databases, storage, routers, switches — the whole lot. And the VP's response? "So what. I can’t ship anything."

That's when the light bulb went off in Joe's head. All the IT technologies that underlie the distribution center were running fine, but not the center itself. IT Operations needed another way to look at things, so he could understand the IT environment's status in terms of its impact on the business, not just in terms of how this or that technology silo was behaving.

Like Heraclitus and the river, Joe needed to strike a balance between experience and reason. Joe had plenty of experience — reams of performance monitoring data and proof of SLA compliance for each technology domain — but no way to reason, or monitor, the distribution center business process itself.

Joe started thinking of ITIL — the framework for orienting IT with services, not technologies, in mind. The trouble is, IT operates in a bubble. In fact, lots of bubbles: silo’d teams, silo’d tools, each separately monitoring servers, applications, storage, databases, routers, switches, etc.. No one was monitoring the big picture outside the bubbles. IT Operations Level 1 (the “first line of defense”) was looking at a sea of monitoring screens, events and alerts about technology devices and circuits, and had little or no understanding about how those events and alerts impacted specific business processes.

So even when IT was meeting SLA objectives in each silo, little degradations (i.e., incidents) across silos were adding up and impacting different services (i.e., processes and user experience) in different ways. This was undetectable because there wasn't any way to way to associate all those incidents with specific business services: no operational view and real-time IT operational analytics of business processes across silos.

This is typical. As an analyst from a leading IT research firm recently told me: "The Industry has been trying to solve this problem for decades. It sounds old, but we keep coming back to the same paradox over and over again."

Joe and others like him have embarked on a mission to transform IT Operations from a purely technology monitoring team to a business service reliability monitoring team. They are transforming operations because either they’ll crack the paradox of managing services that they deliver to their business, or the business will outsource operations to someone who can.

Transformation doesn't happen overnight. As the ITIL mantra teaches us, it takes "people, processes and technology" to get IT properly focused on the business and its services. To start, you need to step outside your bubble.

David Hayward is Senior Principal Manager, Solutions Marketing at CA Technologies.

Hot Topics

The Latest

E-commerce is set to skyrocket with a 9% rise over the next few years ... To thrive in this competitive environment, retailers must identify digital resilience as their top priority. In a world where savvy shoppers expect 24/7 access to online deals and experiences, any unexpected downtime to digital services can lead to significant financial losses, damage to brand reputation, abandoned carts with designer shoes, and additional issues ...

Efficiency is a highly-desirable objective in business ... We're seeing this scenario play out in enterprises around the world as they continue to struggle with infrastructures and remote work models with an eye toward operational efficiencies. In contrast to that goal, a recent Broadcom survey of global IT and network professionals found widespread adoption of these strategies is making the network more complex and hampering observability, leading to uptime, performance and security issues. Let's look more closely at these challenges ...

Image
Broadcom

The 2025 Catchpoint SRE Report dives into the forces transforming the SRE landscape, exploring both the challenges and opportunities ahead. Let's break down the key findings and what they mean for SRE professionals and the businesses relying on them ...

Image
Catchpoint

The pressure on IT teams has never been greater. As data environments grow increasingly complex, resource shortages are emerging as a major obstacle for IT leaders striving to meet the demands of modern infrastructure management ... According to DataStrike's newly released 2025 Data Infrastructure Survey Report, more than half (54%) of IT leaders cite resource limitations as a top challenge, highlighting a growing trend toward outsourcing as a solution ...

Image
Datastrike

Gartner revealed its top strategic predictions for 2025 and beyond. Gartner's top predictions explore how generative AI (GenAI) is affecting areas where most would assume only humans can have lasting impact ...

The adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) is accelerating across the telecoms industry, with 88% of fixed broadband service providers now investigating or trialing AI automation to enhance their fixed broadband services, according to new research from Incognito Software Systems and Omdia ...

 

AWS is a cloud-based computing platform known for its reliability, scalability, and flexibility. However, as helpful as its comprehensive infrastructure is, disparate elements and numerous siloed components make it difficult for admins to visualize the cloud performance in detail. It requires meticulous monitoring techniques and deep visibility to understand cloud performance and analyze operational efficiency in detail to ensure seamless cloud operations ...

Imagine a future where software, once a complex obstacle, becomes a natural extension of daily workflow — an intuitive, seamless experience that maximizes productivity and efficiency. This future is no longer a distant vision but a reality being crafted by the transformative power of Artificial Intelligence ...

Enterprise data sprawl already challenges companies' ability to protect and back up their data. Much of this information is never fully secured, leaving organizations vulnerable. Now, as GenAI platforms emerge as yet another environment where enterprise data is consumed, transformed, and created, this fragmentation is set to intensify ...

Image
Crashplan

OpenTelemetry (OTel) has revolutionized the way we approach observability by standardizing the collection of telemetry data ... Here are five myths — and truths — to help elevate your OTel integration by harnessing the untapped power of logs ...