Why Traditional APM Tools Are Insufficient for Modern Enterprise Applications
September 26, 2019

Navin Israni

Share this

APM tools are your window into your application's performance — its capacity and levels of service. These tools help admins conduct regular health checks on the app so they can tell the state of the app without any ambiguity.

Any application is made up of its layers and its subsystems — the servers, the virtualization layers, the dependencies, and its components. The purpose of such tools has traditionally been to monitor the performance of all the subsystems.

A traditional approach to APM involved the use of arbitrary sampling strategies, algorithm-based data completion, and a fair bit of prediction to analyze the root cause. So, the agents had to come up with a hypothesis of why things were wrong and devise a sampling strategy to test that theory. Any data gaps were predictively filled by algorithms.

Automation is one of the many ways that founders can scale their business. As organizations grow, their automated processes will only generate more data, not less. As automation seeps into every facet of the digital enterprise, the applications interfacing organizations with their audience generate large swathes of raw, unsampled data.

Traditional APM tools are now struggling due to the mismatch between their specifications and expectations.

Modern application architectures are multi-faceted; they contain hybrid components across a variety of on-premise and cloud applications. Modern enterprises often generate data in silos with each outflow having its own data structure. This data comes from several tools over different periods of time.

Such diversity in sources, structure, and formats present unique challenges for traditional enterprise tools.

1. Inability to handle massive, multi-dimensional data

As discussed before, modern applications are not atomic; they are constituent of several components and subsystems all of which contribute to its overall performance. 

Each subsystem can produce several terabytes of data. Such scale of data brings forth at least a few problems with the earlier-generation APM tools:

■ The efficient storage of and access to this data is a peculiar challenge.

■ Real-time analysis of this data on the mammoth-scale is an even bigger challenge for traditional APM tools.

■ Often the data may be multiple types of data sources — in flat files, structured query-based databases, or even complete systems of their own with API-based access.

2. Propagation of fragmentation into APM tools

Often, we see new tools for each functional area even within the same data center. This fuels silo creation as segregated teams support individual tools for managing the server, network, storage, and virtual layers. 

A count of anywhere between 6 to 10 tools would not be uncommon. Each of these proprietary tools may come with vendor lock-in, forcing companies to continue using them with restrictions or pay more when the usage increases.

This is not ideal for enterprises as most modern applications are dynamic and interdependent in nature. For example, as user-base increases, a single business request to increase capacity will mean synchronous updating and coordination among silos for databases, servers, networks, and virtual layers.

At the intersection of these functional areas, agents do the job of coordinating the data and passing on the configurations. Without a cohesive plan to manage these agents (automated or manual), it becomes difficult to collectively address issues to optimize their efficiency. 

Due to the fragmentation in tools, other issues like long-term licensing come to surface and companies have to keep paying for these tools over the long term. One possible solution is to outsource product development. This way companies can target multiple functionalities with a single custom-developed app and finite vendor contracts.

3. Security risks during seasonal spikes

To proactively identify problems, these tools rely on detecting anomalies in data sources that are infrastructure-centric. This would typically include log files, memory metrics, CPU usage, and so on. 

If there are seasonal spikes, such as massive holiday sales like Black Friday, the admins would be flooded with spikes across the board. Hiding an attack in between these spikes becomes easier as most traditional APM tools can't differentiate between these spikes from distributed denial of service (DDoS) attacks.

4. Difficulty in root-cause analysis

Agents can stitch together data from various systems to identify root cause of major problems. To detect anomalies, agents identify patterns and then use queries to confirm their assumptions of a diagnosis.

Because of human involvement in the diagnosis process, there is a strong possibility of selection/sampling bias being introduced in the process.

Also, these analyses are estimates at best as they rely on testing a hypothesis.

An accurate, tools-agnostic analysis of the root cause requires not only identifying anomalies but patterns of these aberrations over time. This is where traditional APM tools fall short and predictive analysis tools truly shine.

Final Words

Traditional APM tools lack the capacity to handle the scale of data being generated by modern applications. Also, these applications generally occupy status of legacy apps in enterprises, which makes replacing them even more difficult.

So, while management is likely to see them as roadblocks, removing these legacy apps completely from the enterprise would mean ripping the band-aid off. It is a hard decision to make and one that requires a fair bit of convincing and strategy.

This might look like hard work, but it is better than letting these roadblocks continue to slow your processes down. It is important to take action before the damage becomes critical.

Navin Israni is a Senior Content Writer at Arkenea
Share this

The Latest

February 27, 2020

The Cloud Performance Benchmark from ThousandEyes compares global network performance and connectivity differences between the five major public cloud providers — Amazon Web Services (AWS), Google Cloud Platform (GCP), Microsoft Azure, Alibaba Cloud and IBM Cloud — proving that, when it comes to performance, not all clouds are created equal ...

February 26, 2020

For the past 10 years, the majority of CIOs have had a transformational focus (currently 42%), however, this year, there is strong momentum in CIOs taking on more strategic responsibilities (40%), according to the 2020 State of the CIO research from IDG's CIO ...

February 25, 2020
A widening gap between IT resources and the demands of managing the increasing scale and complexity of enterprise cloud ecosystems is evident, according to <span style="font-style: italic;">Top challenges for CIOs on the road to the AI-driven autonomous cloud</span>, a new report based on a global survey of 800 CIOs conducted by Vanson Bourne and commissioned by Dynatrace ...
February 24, 2020

The tech world may be falling in love with artificial intelligence and automation, but when it comes to managing critical assets, old school tools like spreadsheets are still in common use. A new survey by Ivanti illustrates how these legacy tools are forcing IT to waste valuable time analyzing assets due to incomplete data ...

February 20, 2020

Over 70% of C-Suite decision makers believe business innovation and staff retention are driven by improved visibility into network and application performance, according to Rethink Possible: Visibility and Network Performance – The Pillars of Business Success, a survey
conducted by Riverbed ...

February 19, 2020

Modern enterprises rely upon their IT departments to deliver a seamless digital customer experience. Performance and availability are the foundational stepping stones to delivering that customer experience. Along those lines, this month we released a new research study titled the IT Downtime Detection and Mitigation Report that contains recommendations on how to best prevent, detect or mitigate brownouts and outages, given the context of today’s IT transformation trends ...

February 18, 2020

While Application Performance Management (APM) has become mainstream, with a majority of tech pros using APM tools regularly, there's work to be done to move beyond troubleshooting ...

February 13, 2020

Over the last few decades, IT departments have decreased budgets in part because of recession. As a result, they have are being asked to do more with less. The increase in work has amplified the need for automation ...

February 12, 2020

Many variables must align for optimum APM, and security is certainly among them. I offer the following APM predictions for 2020, which revolve around the reality that we will definitely begin to see much deeper integration of WAN technology on the security front. Look for this integration to take shape in the following ways ...

February 11, 2020

When it comes to growing a successful company, research shows it isn't about getting the most out of employees, but delivering an experience that empowers them to be and do their best. And according to Priming a New Era of Digital Wellness, a new study conducted by Quartz Insights in partnership with Citrix Systems, technology is the secret to doing so ...