Why Your APM Solutions May Not Be “Cloud-Ready”
February 21, 2012

Julie Craig
EMA

Share this

Public Cloud provides a layer of abstraction between the functionality of a service and its delivery. Put simply, its functionality is unlocked by a credit card versus actual hands-on deployment. This is both a blessing and a curse.

Public Cloud customers are finding that, while Cloud services are easy to consume, they are not as easy to govern and manage. This abstraction layer means that traditional Application Performance Management (APM) solutions may not be as useful as they once were. As a result, many CIOs are finding it necessary to reevaluate management portfolios for Cloud-readiness.

Throughout most of 2011 and into 2012, Enterprise Management Associates’ (EMA) Application Management team conducted back to back research projects on APM for Cloud services. The research began during the Spring of 2011 with survey-based research assessing the impact of Cloud in all its flavors—public, private, and hybrid—on IT organizations.

After publishing the results of this study in August, we utilized the findings to formulate an EMA Radar Report, essentially an assessment of the solutions of eighteen leading APM vendors for “Cloud-readiness”. Released earlier this month (February, 2012), the findings are available for download at. www.emausa.com

The August report revealed that today’s companies are much further along in their Cloud deployments than most experts would have suspected. Nearly 85% are either already using private Cloud or are planning to do so within the next year. For SaaS that number is approximately 75%, for IaaS it is 65%, and for IaaS it stands at approximately 55%.

While these numbers are definitely interesting, to understand the true impact of Cloud it is necessary to take a look at how companies are using these services. After all, regardless of the underlying delivery mechanism, applications are still IT's primary deliverable, and application performance is the key measure of application quality. For this reason, the study also asked detailed questions about enterprise applications, architectures, and the role of Cloud in supporting production applications.

Table 1 shows adoption rates for a variety of deployment patterns for integrated applications. It illustrates the fact that transactions spanning heterogeneous hardware and software platforms are commonplace, definitely mainstream, and that those spanning on-premise and Cloud are not far behind.


Cloud-Ready APM

Patterns 1 and 2 relate to on-premise-hosted transactions. Patterns 3 and 4 relate to transactions touching the public Cloud, and, in the case of Pattern 4, integrations between multiple SaaS platforms.

While most of the APM solutions in the marketplace today were originally engineered to support primarily on-premise applications, many still do not support Patterns 1 and 2. They lack support for transactions spanning on-premise and mainframe or for those spanning Java and .NET.

APM solutions also vary widely in their levels of support for troubleshooting and root cause analysis. If the requirement is to quantify performance and availability, an application performance monitoring solution may suffice. However if there is an additional requirement for in-depth troubleshooting/root cause analysis support, monitoring solutions alone cannot provide adequate depth of visibility.

EMA’s APM taxonomy distinguishes performance monitoring from performance management for just this reason. In doing so, it makes the following distinctions:

Application Management Solutions: These solutions deliver visibility to and control of transactions, applications, and end-to-end services. The terminology covers a broad range of capabilities and products with visibility to application execution from a wide variety of instrumentation points.

Application Performance Monitoring and Application Performance Management are subsets of Application Management that focus on performance. The two classifications differ in their levels of support for troubleshooting and root cause analysis.

- Application Performance Monitoring solutions, such as End User Experience (EUE) management products, assess performance and availability.

- Application Performance Management (APM) solutions also monitor performance but support troubleshooting, problem determination, and root cause analysis as well. In other words, they have some level of visibility to the service model, which is the relationship between “top down” execution and “bottom up” infrastructure.

It is important to understand these distinctions because, although a wide variety of products are being marketed under the “APM” category, they are quite variable in terms of their capabilities. Monitoring solutions tend to be relatively inexpensive and may well be good choices if the requirement is simply to quantify performance and availability. Management capabilities do add cost, but that cost can quickly be recouped when automated troubleshooting replaces “all hands on deck” root cause analysis marathons.

Patterns 3 and 4 are examples of additional reasons why these distinctions are important. The adoption percentages for Pattern 3, for example, demonstrate that on-premise/public Cloud integrations are definitely mainstream deployment patterns. However, APM solutions vary significantly in the way they handle such transactions once they exit the enterprise IT ecosystem.

While virtually all have some depth of visibility to the on-premise segment of end-to-end execution, many see the public Cloud as a “black box”. They can monitor transactions to and from, and in doing so extrapolate “Cloud” performance. However they cannot penetrate beyond (or within) such integrations to a level that supports full-spectrum, tier-based reporting. Such reporting is essential for actually managing and troubleshooting complex applications.

This problem is even more prevalent in Pattern 4 deployments, since the majority of APM solutions have no visibility to the integration technology supporting SaaS to SaaS integrations. This is another case where off-premise tiers appear as a single black box as opposed to a series of steps with quantifications of execution time at each step.

Summary

What does this all this mean to CIO’s? One global bank is monitoring performance of customer applications from multiple locations worldwide. When they receive performance alerts, they manually triage to determine whether the problem is from all locations or a single location. They then do further manual triage to determine the actual problem source. Sound familiar? It should, because this is the same, quintessential problem-solving paradigm IT has utilized for eons—only now it is on a broader scale.

Cloud, particularly public Cloud, means that the underlying structure of transactions and applications becomes more opaque. Performance problems become more difficult to troubleshoot. Supporting these new distributed applications cost-effectively requires APM solutions that are up to the task. Now is a good time for CIOs and their teams to reevaluate and, if necessary, shore up their APM solutions to accommodate this new complexity. Otherwise, it is far too easy to end up with the “same old same old”— fifteen IT specialists missing their kid’s soccer games to figure out why business critical services aren’t performing to user expectations.

Julie Craig is Research Director for Application Management at Enterprise Management Associates (EMA)
Share this

The Latest

May 26, 2020

Nearly 3,700 people told GitLab about their DevOps journeys. Respondents shared that their roles are changing dramatically, no matter where they sit in the organization. The lines surrounding the traditional definitions of dev, sec, ops and test have blurred, and as we enter the second half of 2020, it is perhaps more important than ever for companies to understand how these roles are evolving ...

May 21, 2020

As cloud computing continues to grow, tech pros say they are increasingly prioritizing areas like hybrid infrastructure management, application performance management (APM), and security management to optimize delivery for the organizations they serve, according to SolarWinds IT Trends Report 2020: The Universal Language of IT ...

May 20, 2020

Businesses see digital experience as a growing priority and a key to their success, with execution requiring a more integrated approach across development, IT and business users, according to Digital Experiences: Where the Industry Stands ...

May 19, 2020

Fully 90% of those who use observability tooling say those tools are important to their team's software development success, including 39% who say observability tools are very important ...

May 18, 2020

As our production application systems continuously increase in complexity, the challenges of understanding, debugging, and improving them keep growing by orders of magnitude. The practice of Observability addresses both the social and the technological challenges of wrangling complexity and working toward achieving production excellence. New research shows how observable systems and practices are changing the APM landscape ...

May 14, 2020
Digital technologies have enveloped our lives like never before. Be it on the personal or professional front, we have become dependent on the accurate functioning of digital devices and the software running them. The performance of the software is critical in running the components and levers of the new digital ecosystem. And to ensure our digital ecosystem delivers the required outcomes, a robust performance testing strategy should be instituted ...
May 13, 2020

The enforced change to working from home (WFH) has had a massive impact on businesses, not just in the way they manage their employees and IT systems. As the COVID-19 pandemic progresses, enterprise IT teams are looking to answer key questions such as: Which applications have become more critical for working from home? ...

May 12, 2020

In ancient times — February 2020 — EMA research found that more than 50% of IT leaders surveyed were considering new ITSM platforms in the near future. The future arrived with a bang as IT organizations turbo-pivoted to deliver and support unprecedented levels and types of services to a global workplace suddenly working from home ...

May 11, 2020

The Internet of Things (IoT) is changing the world. From augmented reality advanced analytics to new consumer solutions, IoT and the cloud are together redefining both how we work and how we engage with our audiences. They are changing how we live, as well ...

May 07, 2020

Despite IT professionals' confidence in their ability to support today's much greater dependence on digital services, there is a rise in application performance errors reported by more than half of consumers, according to the Impact of COVID-19 on Digital Transformation survey from xMatters ...